TODAY In Columnists ›
David Mckay
Law and justice
David Mckay | Mon, 08 Jun 2009 10:01[miningmx.com] -- A FAVOURITE yarn is that you can enter a gold mine at Nigel, in the far east Rand, and only resurface at another in Randfontein in the west Rand. I'm not sure if that's accurate, but the interconnectedness of the Witwatersrand's gold mines, with its labyrinth of declines, conduits and inclines, is just one of the reasons illegal underground gold mining is rife. The other is corruption. Harmony Gold suspended 77 workers last week for allegedly assisting illegal underground mining at its Eland shaft. That's quite a support staff for the 200-plus illegal miners so far discovered at the operation. It hints at just how widespread the practice of illegal gold mining is in South Africa. I spoke this week with a former executive of a South African gold mining company, who admitted that illegal mining was endemic and impossible to police. But I was also astonished at how low-key the criminality is. For instance, fake ID documents allow criminals to access a mine, normally when the pump shift is going down during the early hours, or they get through the turnstyles in twos. And if the cage is not full, so much the better as it's easier to slip in one or two criminals unnoticed. They just stroll in. Once underground, the illegal miners head for unused areas (but not only) which have either been closed down because it's not commercial to mine there, or it's too dangerous. If the area has been plugged shut, often with concrete and timber, the illegal miners will blast it away with dynamite stolen from underground stores. Remember, once beneath the earth, illegal miners are almost impossible to detect, invisible almost. The entire mine infrastructure is theirs to plunder. They often head for narrow reefs - areas where a seam of gold-bearing rock snakes through the tonnes of rock above and beneath it - and manually scrape out the ore. Given the micro-attention they pay to such deposits, a grade of 40g per tonne of rock is retrieved whereas a company, working on the basis of extracting as much volume as possible, will achieve a mere 4g or 8g/tonne from the same reef. High-grade ore is then crushed underground with a makeshift milling instrument, such as a gas bottle. Smelting is performed with a cutting torch. Further smelting happens on surface, where the unrefined gold is taken by "carriers" in return for food supplies. So who carries the can? That's because the illegal miners, who incidentally are the poorest paid in the whole crooked syndicate, will work a one-month shift or more, turning yellow from light deprivation. Harmony is by no means the only company facing gold theft in this manner, but the fact that it dominates certain regions suggests that it is particularly vulnerable to piracy. In the Free State, it's possible to descend into St Helena mine, owned by Harmony, and resurface at the group's Masimong about 20km to 30km away. Similarly, Harmony's Randfontein and Ezulwini operations are linked underground to Gold Fields' South Deep mine, again many surface kilometres removed. Who is responsible? Mining executives would fairly argue that it's impossible to be responsible for illegal underground mining, but that's unlikely to cut the mustard with the minerals and energy department if certain aspects of the Mine Health and Safety Amendment Act, gazetted on April 17, are any guide. What stands out from the amendments is that a fresh interpretation of reasonable steps to avoid injury and death is emerging. Thus in section 86A of the act, it's not now possible for CEOs to defend themselves from culpability in the event of a fatal accident by saying a general order or instruction had been issued to operate safely. Here's the act verbatim if you don't believe me: "[The] fact that the person issued instructions prohibiting the performance or an omission is not in itself sufficient proof that all reasonable steps were taken to prevent the performance or omission." Similarly, CEOs or the company cannot evade responsibility for a fatal accident by blaming it on the victim's actions. I took this to a Johannesburg-based labour attorney with a strong interest in the mining industry. "The test of negligence in the past led to a causal chain of events, and it was often shown that someone lower down had been responsible. "In that light, it was hard to blame the CEO. Now, there's a clear attempt to make CEOs more accountable," the attorney says. CEOs in the spotlight And how! According to the amendments, punishments on CEOs in their personal capacity for fatal accidents ranges from R50 000 or six months in jail to R1m or five years behind bars. It seems enormously unfair to believe Harmony CEO Graham Briggs is responsible for the 76 deaths of criminals operating illegally on his mine, but in a climate of new legislation, and with high awareness of the recent spate of fatal accidents, what are the chances he could fall under the microscope? "The effect of the mine's activities on the community around me is very much part of health and safety legislation," the attorney says. That's true. Dust blowing off a tailings dam is an indirect hazard of gold mining. "But the law also requires a bit of common sense," the attorney says. But I leave the final word with Sandile Nogxina, director-general of the minerals department and a former advocate. In an interview on Friday, he said CEOs can't insulate themselves by blaming fatal accidents on the actions of others. "If there is a death on a mine, the CEO becomes vicariously liable," he says. "If you have a car accident and someone dies, the courts will decide if you are responsible. So we're saying issues such as fatalities on mines are a question of common law in just the same way. "In that case, the Inspector of Mines can't take action, but he must certainly refer the matter to the prosecuting authorities," he says. "CEOs can be imprisoned if there is negligence. If there is a nexus between the CEO's behaviour and death, he must be answerable."
USER COMMENTS () Click to View
COMMENT
SHARE
E-MAIL
PRINT
MORE FROM OUR COLUMNISTS
Most Read
Commented
Editor's Choice
- »Kumba halts cheap iron ore to ArcelorMittal SA
by Allan Seccombe | 26 Feb 2010 13:12 - »Barrick chasing Randgold premium
by David McKay | 28 Feb 2010 10:59 - »First Uranium soars on tailings news
by Allan Seccombe | 26 Feb 2010 10:24 - »Petra sells diamond for $35.3m
by Reuters | 26 Feb 2010 12:18 - »Barrick chasing Randgold premium
by David McKay | 28 Feb 2010 10:59
- » Kumba halts cheap iron ore to ArcelorMittal SA
by Kumba halts cheap iron ore to ArcelorMittal SA | 26 Feb 2010 13:12 - » Exxaro wants BEE equity changes
by Exxaro wants BEE equity changes | 25 Feb 2010 16:39 - » Aurora defends gold mine plans
by Aurora defends gold mine plans | 22 Feb 2010 18:07 - » Gold Fields lowers gold outlook, again
by Gold Fields lowers gold outlook, again | 23 Feb 2010 13:38 - » Bateman exodus continues
by Bateman exodus continues | 17 Feb 2010 17:02 - » Xstrata pays dividend, upbeat on markets
by Xstrata pays dividend, upbeat on markets | 08 Feb 2010 10:58 - » AngloPlat turns the corner
by AngloPlat turns the corner | 08 Feb 2010 17:07 - » Copper prices destined for record high
by Copper prices destined for record high | 01 Feb 2010 14:29 - » Good prospects for gold
by Good prospects for gold | 01 Feb 2010 19:30 - » Bernard Swanepoel's first platinum play
by Bernard Swanepoel's first platinum play | 29 Jan 2010 16:43 - » Anglo Coal gets out of Venezuela
by Anglo Coal gets out of Venezuela | 29 Jan 2010 10:37 - » Three new coal listings for the JSE
by Three new coal listings for the JSE | 28 Jan 2010 11:09 - » Harmony streamlines ops, targets growth
by Harmony streamlines ops, targets growth | 26 Jan 2010 09:59 - » Simmers settles board battle
by Simmers settles board battle | 22 Jan 2010 11:43 - » Decision time looms at AngloPlat
by Decision time looms at AngloPlat | 22 Jan 2010 08:40 - » Eddie du Rand quits Bateman
by Eddie du Rand quits Bateman | 15 Jan 2010 13:21 - » Aurora buys DRDGOLD's ERPM plant
by Aurora buys DRDGOLD's ERPM plant | 17 Jan 2010 10:42 - » Kazakh firm eyes Mvela
by Kazakh firm eyes Mvela | 04 Jan 2010 13:41 - » Namakwa gets new Lesotho mine
by Namakwa gets new Lesotho mine | 05 Jan 2010 15:28 - » Gold latest in decade of bubbles
by Gold latest in decade of bubbles | 04 Jan 2010 10:40 - » BEE imbroglio to inform charter debate
by BEE imbroglio to inform charter debate | 18 Dec 2009 08:00 - » Solomon regains Wesizwe control
by Solomon regains Wesizwe control | 17 Dec 2009 15:12 - » Aurora says it is financially sound
by Aurora says it is financially sound | 03 Dec 2009 17:26 - » Wesizwe is being "hijacked"
by Wesizwe is being "hijacked" | 03 Dec 2009 02:00 - » DRDGOLD sells Blyvoor to Aurora
by DRDGOLD sells Blyvoor to Aurora | 02 Dec 2009 15:18 - » Exxaro cuts mineral sands for coal
by Exxaro cuts mineral sands for coal | 01 Dec 2009 17:44 - » Bakubung calls for its Wesizwe directors to quit
by Bakubung calls for its Wesizwe directors to quit | 26 Nov 2009 11:36 - » Wesizwe Platinum wracked by coup allegations
by Wesizwe Platinum wracked by coup allegations | 25 Nov 2009 11:51 - » Global gold hedge heads below 10moz
by Global gold hedge heads below 10moz | 17 Nov 2009 13:34 - » Platinum deficit forecast for 2010
by Platinum deficit forecast for 2010 | 17 Nov 2009 15:03 - » Uranium One cuts production target
by Uranium One cuts production target | 16 Nov 2009 10:12 - » Is silver's salvation upon us?
by Is silver's salvation upon us? | 13 Nov 2009 15:23 - » Maroga definitely out - Eskom board
by Maroga definitely out - Eskom board | 12 Nov 2009 12:56 - » Ferrochrome users landed with SA energy costs
by Ferrochrome users landed with SA energy costs | 12 Nov 2009 12:52 - » Eskom: Principle vs power
by Eskom: Principle vs power | 10 Nov 2009 12:10
Podcasts
RSS Feeds
Jobs
Events
JSE Listed stocksReal time resources data.
FREE News Alert! Subscribe to our News Alert